TypeError: Descriptors cannot be created directly - Fix

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

The error "TypeError: Descriptors cannot not be created directly" is a common stumbling block for developers working with Protobuf, particularly after upgrading to a newer version. This error indicates a mismatch between your installed Protobuf library and the generated Python code derived from your .proto files.

The error "TypeError: Descriptors cannot not be created directly" often pops up when working with Protobuf, especially after upgrading to a newer version. This error signals an incompatibility between your Protobuf version and the generated code from your .proto files.

Here's a breakdown of how to fix it:

1. Downgrade Protobuf: The quickest solution is often to revert to an older, compatible Protobuf version. You can do this using pip:

   pip install protobuf==3.20.1 

   Replace 3.20.1 with the version that works for your setup.

2. Regenerate Protobuf Code: If downgrading isn't ideal, you need to regenerate the Python code from your .proto definition files. Ensure you have the latest protoc compiler installed, then run:

   protoc --python_out=. your_proto_file.proto

   This command generates updated _pb2.py files that align with your current Protobuf version.

3. Check for Conflicting Dependencies: Sometimes, other libraries might indirectly force an incompatible Protobuf version. Analyze your project's requirements.txt or environment for potential conflicts and try resolving them.

4. Platform-Specific Considerations:

   • Streamlit Cloud: Streamlit Cloud might have specific Protobuf versions it supports. Refer to their documentation or support for guidance.

   • Docker: If using Docker, rebuild your image after updating Protobuf or regenerating code to ensure consistency.

5. Additional Tips:

   • Virtual Environments: Always work within a virtual environment to isolate project dependencies and prevent version clashes.

   • Clear Caches: Clear your package manager's cache (e.g., pip cache purge) and try reinstalling or upgrading Protobuf.

Remember to restart your Python kernel or application after making changes to ensure they take effect.

This Python code defines a function to regenerate Python code from a Protobuf definition file (.proto). It uses the 'protoc' command-line tool to perform the code generation. The script takes the path to the .proto file as input and handles potential errors during the process. The main execution block demonstrates how to use the function by specifying a placeholder for the .proto file path. To use the script, replace the placeholder with the actual path to your .proto file and run it.

import os
import subprocess

# Example: Regenerating Protobuf code

def regenerate_protobuf_code(proto_file):
    """Regenerates Python code from a .proto file.

    Args:
        proto_file: Path to the .proto file.
    """

    try:
        # Assuming protoc is in your PATH
        subprocess.run(["protoc", f"--python_out=.", proto_file], check=True)
        print(f"Successfully regenerated code for: {proto_file}")
    except FileNotFoundError:
        print("Error: protoc not found. Make sure it's installed and in your PATH.")
    except subprocess.CalledProcessError as e:
        print(f"Error during code generation: {e}")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    proto_file_path = "your_proto_file.proto"  # Replace with your .proto file path
    regenerate_protobuf_code(proto_file_path)

Explanation:

1. Import Necessary Modules:

   • os: Used for potential path manipulation (not directly used in this example, but good practice).
   • subprocess: Used to execute the protoc command.

2. regenerate_protobuf_code Function:

   • Takes the path to your .proto file as input.
   • Uses subprocess.run() to execute the protoc command:
     • protoc: The Protobuf compiler.
     • --python_out=.: Specifies to generate Python code in the current directory.
     • proto_file: The path to your .proto file.
   • Includes error handling:
     • FileNotFoundError: If protoc is not found in your system's PATH.
     • subprocess.CalledProcessError: If the protoc command fails for any reason.

3. Main Execution Block:

   • if __name__ == "__main__":: Ensures the code runs only when the script is executed directly.
   • proto_file_path: Replace this with the actual path to your .proto file.
   • Calls the regenerate_protobuf_code function to regenerate the code.

How to Use:

1. Save the code: Save the code as a Python file (e.g., regenerate_proto.py).
2. Replace placeholder: Change your_proto_file.proto to the actual path of your .proto file.
3. Run the script: Open your terminal, navigate to the directory where you saved the script, and run:

   python regenerate_proto.py

This script will attempt to regenerate the Python code for your Protobuf definitions. Make sure you have protoc installed and accessible in your PATH.

Here are some extra points to consider, expanding on the original information:

Understanding the Root Cause:

• Protobuf's Evolution: Protobuf, like many libraries, undergoes changes that sometimes break backward compatibility. This error often arises from using generated code (from an older Protobuf version) with a newer, incompatible Protobuf library.
• Descriptors: Descriptors are internal Protobuf components that define how your data is structured (messages, fields, etc.). Version mismatches can lead to these descriptors being interpreted incorrectly.

Troubleshooting and Best Practices:

• Isolate the Issue: If you have multiple .proto files, try regenerating them one by one to pinpoint the specific file causing the problem.
• Version Pinning: In your requirements.txt or environment management system, specify the exact Protobuf version that works to avoid unexpected upgrades.
• Stay Updated (Cautiously): While upgrading Protobuf can bring benefits, do so with caution. Test thoroughly after upgrades, especially if you're working on a large or complex project.
• Community Resources: The Protobuf community is active. Search online forums and the Protobuf issue tracker – you're likely not the first to encounter this error.

Beyond the Error:

• Protobuf Fundamentals: A solid understanding of Protobuf basics (messages, fields, data types) will help you diagnose and resolve issues more effectively.
• Code Generation Process: Familiarize yourself with the protoc compiler and its options. Understanding how code generation works is crucial for long-term Protobuf usage.

This error, while frustrating, is usually solvable with a systematic approach. By understanding the cause and following the recommended steps, you can get your Protobuf code up and running smoothly.

This error usually means your Protobuf version and generated code are incompatible. Here's how to fix it:

Additional Tips:

• Use virtual environments to isolate project dependencies.
• Clear package manager caches if facing installation issues.
• Restart your Python kernel or application after making changes.

To summarize, encountering the "TypeError: Descriptors cannot not be created directly" error in your Protobuf code signals an incompatibility issue, typically arising from version discrepancies between your Protobuf library and generated code. The most common solutions involve either downgrading your Protobuf library to a compatible version or regenerating your Protobuf code using the latest protoc compiler. Additionally, it's crucial to scrutinize your project for conflicting dependencies and consider platform-specific requirements. Remember to leverage virtual environments, clear caches when necessary, and restart your Python kernel or application to ensure changes take effect. By understanding the root cause and following these troubleshooting steps, you can effectively address this error and ensure the smooth operation of your Protobuf code.

• TypeError: Descriptors cannot not be created directly. - protobuf ... | System Info transformers version: 4.25.1 Platform: Windows-10-10.0.19045-SP0 Python version: 3.8.15 Huggingface_hub version: 0.10.1 PyTorch version (GPU?): 1.13.1 (True) Tensorflow version (GPU?): ...
• TypeError: Descriptors cannot not be created directly - Community ... | I get the following error when deploying the app. I dont use the package mentioned in the erorr, any ideas? Error: ❗️ Error during processing dependencies! Please fix the error and push an update, or try restarting the app. Traceback (most recent call last): File "/home/appuser/venv/bin/streamlit", line 5, in from streamlit.cli import main File "/home/appuser/venv/lib/python3.9/site-packages/streamlit/init.py", line 48, in from streamlit.proto.RootContain...
• Sudden TypeError - Descriptors cannot not be created directly ... | Summary I was using the image python:3.9.13-slim to deploy a container that uses tensorflow and other libraries. Everything was okay but with the latest image release at the moment of writting: Dig...
• Issue with Protocol Buffers - Community Cloud - Streamlit | Hi everyone, I recently tried to upgrade my app in Streamlit Cloud and got a TypeError (See the error message below). I was able to temporarily fix the issue by including the following line on my requirements.txt file: protobuf==3.20.1 It seems that Google has made some breaking changes to their Cloud Platform to take advantage of Python 4.21+ performance improvements. Streamlit Cloud doesn’t support that version of Python, thus the error. More info on Google Cloud’s docs and this GitHub th...
• Solved: Importing TensorFlow is giving an error when runni ... | Error stack trace: TypeError: Descriptors cannot not be created directly. If this call came from a _pb2.py file, your generated code is out of date and must be regenerated with protoc >= 3.19.0. If you cannot immediately regenerate your protos, some other possible workarounds are:

1. Downgr...

• Troubleshoot descriptors cannot not be created directly - Azure ... | Troubleshooting steps when you get the "descriptors cannot not be created directly" message.
• Type error while deploying streamlit website - Render | when deploying the website the build is succesfull and started the services by streamlit run app.py there is an type error how to fix it?
• "TypeError: Descriptors cannot be created directly" error when ... | Been following the installation steps ml-agents/docs/Installation.md at release_18_docs · Unity-Technologies/ml-agents · GitHub and currently I’m getting stuck on the Installing mlagents step, after installation when I try running mlagents-learn --help I see this in the cmd: Traceback (most recent call last): File “C:\Users\Jax\AppData\Local\Programs\Python\Python38\lib\runpy.py”, line 192, in _run_module_as_main return run_code(code, main_globals, None, File “C:\Users\Jax\AppData\Local\Prog...
• How to Fix the "TypeError: descriptors cannot be created directly" in ... | A Computer Science portal for geeks. It contains well written, well thought and well explained computer science and programming articles, quizzes and practice/competitive programming/company interview Questions.