TensorFlow Stable Results: Setting Random Seed for Reproducibility

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

In the realm of TensorFlow, achieving reproducible results requires taming the element of randomness. This guide outlines essential steps to ensure consistency in your TensorFlow workflows. We'll cover setting global and operation-level seeds, addressing NumPy's influence, and providing specific guidance for Keras users. Additionally, we'll touch upon the nuances of GPU non-determinism and the importance of staying updated with TensorFlow's evolving behavior.

To ensure consistent results in TensorFlow, you need to control the randomness. Here's how:

1. Set Global Seed: Use tf.random.set_seed(seed_value) to initialize the global random seed. Replace seed_value with an integer.

   import tensorflow as tf
   tf.random.set_seed(42) 

2. Set Operation-Level Seed: Some operations have their own seeds. Set them using the seed parameter within the operation.

   tf.random.uniform(shape=(2, 2), seed=123)

3. Consider NumPy Seed: TensorFlow might use NumPy operations internally. Set NumPy's seed using np.random.seed(seed_value).

   import numpy as np
   np.random.seed(42)

4. Keras Users: If using Keras, set seeds for Python, NumPy, and TensorFlow. Additionally, specify a seed within Keras layers that use randomness (e.g., Dropout(rate=0.5, seed=123)).

   import random
   random.seed(42)

Important Notes:

• GPU Non-determinism: GPUs can introduce randomness. For strict reproducibility on GPUs, you might need to enable deterministic behavior, which can impact performance. Refer to TensorFlow's documentation for GPU-specific settings.

• Framework Updates: TensorFlow's behavior might change between versions. Always consult the documentation for the specific version you're using.

This Python code demonstrates how to set seeds for reproducibility in TensorFlow and Keras. It sets global seeds for TensorFlow, NumPy, and Python's random module. It shows how to set an operation-level seed in TensorFlow and how to set a seed for the Dropout layer and optimizer in Keras. The code includes a simple Keras model trained on example data. The code emphasizes the importance of setting seeds for consistent results but notes that achieving full determinism on GPUs might require additional settings and that TensorFlow's random behavior can vary between versions.

import tensorflow as tf
import numpy as np
import random

# Set global seed for TensorFlow
tf.random.set_seed(42)

# Set seed for NumPy
np.random.seed(42)

# Set seed for Python's random module
random.seed(42)

# Example of operation-level seed
random_tensor = tf.random.uniform(shape=(2, 2), seed=123)
print("Random Tensor with Operation-Level Seed:\n", random_tensor)

# Example with Keras
from tensorflow import keras

# Define a simple model
model = keras.Sequential(
    [
        keras.layers.Dense(16, activation="relu", input_shape=(8,)),
        keras.layers.Dropout(rate=0.5, seed=123),  # Set seed for Dropout layer
        keras.layers.Dense(1, activation="sigmoid"),
    ]
)

# Compile the model (using a fixed seed for optimizer initialization)
model.compile(loss="binary_crossentropy", optimizer=keras.optimizers.Adam(seed=42))

# Example data
X = np.random.rand(100, 8)
y = np.random.randint(2, size=100)

# Train the model
model.fit(X, y, epochs=5)

Explanation:

1. Import Libraries: Import necessary libraries like TensorFlow, NumPy, and random.
2. Set Seeds: Set seeds for TensorFlow, NumPy, and Python's random module to ensure consistency across different runs.
3. Operation-Level Seed: Demonstrate how to set a seed for a specific TensorFlow operation (here, tf.random.uniform).
4. Keras Example:
   • Create a simple Keras model with a Dropout layer.
   • Set the seed within the Dropout layer using the seed parameter.
   • Compile the model using an optimizer with a fixed seed.
   • Train the model on some example data.

Important Considerations:

• GPU Determinism: Remember that for strict reproducibility on GPUs, you might need to enable deterministic GPU operations in TensorFlow, which can affect performance.
• TensorFlow Versions: TensorFlow's random number generation behavior might change across versions. Always refer to the documentation for your specific version.

Beyond the Basics:

• Data Shuffling: If you're shuffling your data during training, ensure you use a seeded shuffle function or fix the shuffle order for reproducibility.
• Parallelism: When using multiple threads or processes (e.g., for data loading or distributed training), carefully manage how operations are seeded and distributed to maintain consistency.
• Custom Operations: If you're using custom TensorFlow operations (written in C++/CUDA), ensure they also adhere to seeding principles for random number generation.

Debugging and Best Practices:

• Incremental Testing: When debugging reproducibility issues, start by simplifying your code and gradually add complexity, verifying consistency at each step.
• Seed Logging: Log the seeds used at different levels (global, operation, framework) to aid in reproducing results later.
• Version Control: Keep track of TensorFlow and library versions to isolate potential sources of variation.

Trade-offs and Considerations:

• Performance Impact: Enabling strict determinism, especially on GPUs, can sometimes come with a performance cost. Consider the trade-off between reproducibility and speed based on your application's requirements.
• Practical Reproducibility: While aiming for bit-for-bit reproducibility is ideal, it might not always be feasible or necessary. Focus on achieving a level of reproducibility that aligns with your project's goals and constraints.

Keeping Up-to-Date:

• TensorFlow Documentation: Always refer to the official TensorFlow documentation for the specific version you're using, as recommendations and behavior related to randomness can change.
• Community Resources: Stay engaged with the TensorFlow community (forums, GitHub issues) to learn about best practices, potential pitfalls, and updates related to reproducibility.

This table summarizes how to ensure consistent results in TensorFlow by managing randomness:

Additional Considerations:

• GPU Non-determinism: GPUs can introduce randomness. For strict reproducibility on GPUs, enable deterministic behavior (may impact performance).
• Framework Updates: TensorFlow's behavior might change between versions. Consult the documentation for your specific version.

By meticulously managing randomness in TensorFlow, you can ensure that your experiments and models yield consistent, reproducible results. This involves setting seeds at various levels, understanding the potential for GPU non-determinism, and staying informed about TensorFlow's evolving behavior across versions. Remember that achieving perfect reproducibility can be challenging, especially in complex distributed environments. However, by following the guidelines and best practices outlined in this article, you can significantly enhance the reliability and trustworthiness of your TensorFlow projects.

• Random Seed TensorFlow - How to obtain stable results with a model | In this article, I'll show you how to use a Random Seed with TensorFlow to achieve reproducible results with your model.
• python - TensorFlow: Non-repeatable results - Stack Overflow | Jul 19, 2016 ... You need to set operation level seed in addition to graph-level seed, ie tf.reset_default_graph() a = tf.constant([1, 1, 1, 1, 1], ...
• Each time I run the Keras, I get different result. · Issue #2743 · keras ... | Each time I run the Keras, I get inconsistent result. Is there any way that it converges to the same solution as we have 'random_state' in sklearn which helps us getting the same solution how many ...
• python - Reproducible results in Tensorflow with tf ... | Jul 9, 2018 ... In tensorflow, a random operation relies on two different seeds: a global seed, set by tf.set_random_seed , and an operation seed, ...
• Stumbling backwards into np.random.seed through jax. - Ian Quah | Spoiler: We’ve all been using randomness wrong
• No reproducible using tensorflow backend · Issue #2280 · keras ... | with theano backend (CPU or GPU without cnDNN), I could train reproducible model by fixed_seed_num = 1234 nunpy.random.seed(fixed_seed_num) random.seed(fixed_seed_num) # not sure if needed or not W...
• Different results for the model every time I train the model with same ... | Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 4 votes and 30 comments
• My code needs a very specific random seed not to get stuck at the ... | I made a very simple 3-layered fully-connected network for binary classification (using NASA C-MAPSS dataset to classify healthy and faulty turbofan engines). the input is vector of length 26 and the output is a sigmoid activation. The task is pretty easy (a basic logistic regression model gives me 100% test accuracy), I’m porting this code from Keras (where everything worked as expected) but when executing PyTorch code the loss doesn’t change. Executing the exact same code different times, most...
• How to Get Reproducible Results with Keras ... | Neural network algorithms are stochastic. This means they make use of randomness, such as initializing to random weights, and in turn the same network trained on the same data can produce different results. This can be confusing to beginners as the algorithm appears unstable, and in fact they are by design. The random initialization allows […]