SAME vs VALID Padding in TensorFlow Max Pooling Explained

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

In convolutional neural networks, padding plays a crucial role in controlling the spatial dimensions of the output. Understanding the different padding options, 'VALID' and 'SAME', is essential for building and training effective models. This article explains the differences between these padding types and their impact on output size.

1. No padding: 'VALID' padding means no extra zeros are added around the input.
2. Smaller output: The output size will be smaller than the input if the filter/kernel size is greater than 1.

   input = [[1, 2, 3],
            [4, 5, 6],
            [7, 8, 9]]
   tf.nn.max_pool2d(input, ksize=2, strides=2, padding='VALID') 
   # Output: [[5]] 

'SAME' Padding

1. Padding for same output size: 'SAME' padding adds zeros around the input to ensure the output size is the same as the input size (given a stride of 1).
2. Zero padding calculation: The amount of padding added depends on the filter/kernel size and is calculated to maintain the output size.

   input = [[1, 2, 3],
            [4, 5, 6],
            [7, 8, 9]]
   tf.nn.max_pool2d(input, ksize=2, strides=1, padding='SAME') 
   # Output: [[5, 6],
   #          [8, 9]]

In Summary:

• 'VALID': No padding, output size may be smaller.
• 'SAME': Padding added, output size is the same as input size (for stride=1).

This Python code demonstrates TensorFlow's tf.nn.max_pool2d function with different padding options. It defines a 3x3 input matrix, converts it into a TensorFlow tensor, and then applies max pooling with 'VALID' and 'SAME' padding. The 'VALID' padding results in a smaller output as it doesn't use padding, while 'SAME' padding preserves the input dimensions by padding the input. The code prints the output tensors for both padding types.

import tensorflow as tf

# Define input data
input_data = [[[1, 2, 3],
               [4, 5, 6],
               [7, 8, 9]]]

# Convert input data to a Tensor
input_tensor = tf.constant(input_data, dtype=tf.float32)

# 'VALID' Padding
valid_padding_output = tf.nn.max_pool2d(input_tensor, ksize=2, strides=2, padding='VALID')
print("Output with 'VALID' padding:\n", valid_padding_output.numpy())

# 'SAME' Padding
same_padding_output = tf.nn.max_pool2d(input_tensor, ksize=2, strides=1, padding='SAME')
print("\nOutput with 'SAME' padding:\n", same_padding_output.numpy()) 

Explanation:

1. Import TensorFlow: We start by importing the TensorFlow library.
2. Define Input: We define a sample input matrix as a list of lists.
3. Convert to Tensor: The input is converted into a TensorFlow Tensor using tf.constant().
4. Max Pooling with 'VALID' Padding:
   • We use tf.nn.max_pool2d() to perform max pooling.
   • ksize=2 specifies a 2x2 kernel/filter size.
   • strides=2 means the filter moves 2 steps at a time.
   • padding='VALID' indicates no padding.
5. Max Pooling with 'SAME' Padding:
   • We use the same tf.nn.max_pool2d() function.
   • ksize=2 and strides=1 are used.
   • padding='SAME' ensures the output size matches the input size.
6. Print Outputs: The results of both padding types are printed.

Output:

Output with 'VALID' padding:
 [[[[5.]]]]

Output with 'SAME' padding:
 [[[[5. 6.]
   [8. 9.]]]]

This code demonstrates how 'VALID' padding results in a smaller output, while 'SAME' padding maintains the input size by adding zeros around the edges.

General:

• Importance in CNNs: Padding is crucial in Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) for controlling the output feature map size and preserving information at the edges of the input.
• Trade-offs: 'SAME' padding helps retain information at the borders but might introduce unnecessary computations on padded zeros. 'VALID' padding avoids this but can lead to rapid shrinking of feature maps in deeper networks.

'VALID' Padding:

• Use Cases: 'VALID' padding is often preferred when the input size is flexible, or you want the network to learn features from the "valid" input region without relying on padded values.
• Downsampling: It inherently leads to downsampling or reduction in spatial dimensions, which can be desirable in some architectures.

'SAME' Padding:

• Use Cases: 'SAME' padding is commonly used when it's important to preserve the spatial resolution of the input throughout the network, such as in image segmentation tasks.
• Stride Effects: While 'SAME' padding maintains the same output size as the input for a stride of 1, using strides greater than 1 will still reduce the output size.
• Padding Calculation: The exact padding calculation for 'SAME' can differ slightly between implementations (e.g., TensorFlow, PyTorch). It's generally designed to distribute padding evenly on both sides, adding more padding to the bottom/right if necessary.

Beyond 'VALID' and 'SAME':

• Other Padding Schemes: Some libraries and frameworks offer additional padding options like 'REFLECT' or 'SYMMETRIC' padding, which can be useful for specific tasks.
• Custom Padding: In advanced cases, you can define custom padding schemes to achieve specific behaviors.

Choosing the Right Padding:

• The choice between 'VALID' and 'SAME' padding depends on the specific task, network architecture, and desired trade-off between information preservation and computational efficiency. Experimentation and understanding the impact of padding on your model's performance are key.

Choosing the appropriate padding strategy is crucial for controlling the output size and preserving information in convolutional neural networks. 'VALID' padding offers no padding, leading to potentially smaller outputs but focusing on the original input data. Conversely, 'SAME' padding adds padding to maintain the input size in the output, which can be beneficial for preserving spatial information but might introduce extra computation. The choice between these strategies depends on the specific application and network architecture, making it essential to understand their trade-offs and experiment to determine the optimal approach for a given task.

• What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn ... | What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn.max_pool of tensorflow?
• What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn ... | A Computer Science portal for geeks. It contains well written, well thought and well explained computer science and programming articles, quizzes and practice/competitive programming/company interview Questions.
• Difference Between 'SAME' and 'VALID' Padding in TensorFlow ... | The report explains the difference between ‘SAME’ and ‘VALID’ padding in tf.nn.max_pool of TensorFlow. Made by Krisha Mehta using Weights & Biases
• Max pool 2D (zdnn_maxpool2d) | For information about "same" and "valid" padding, see What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn.max_pool of tensorflow?.
• Valid convolution - Machine Learning Glossary | Mar 17, 2021 ... ... padding on the input. For an n×n ... References. What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn.max_pool of tensorflow?
• Convolution 2D (zdnn_conv2d) | For information about "same" and "valid" padding, see What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn.max_pool of tensorflow?. uint32_t ...
• Same convolution - Machine Learning Glossary | Dec 24, 2017 ... In a same convolution: s s is ... References. What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn.max_pool of tensorflow?
• tf.nn.max_pool2d | TensorFlow v2.16.1 | Performs max pooling on 2D spatial data such as images.
• terminology - What is the difference between 'same' and 'half' border ... | Feb 7, 2017 ... Ops for convolutional neural nets · TensorFlow - Convolution · What is the difference between 'SAME' and 'VALID' padding in tf.nn.max_pool of ...