CNN Image Resizing: Padding vs No Padding for Aspect Ratio

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

When preparing images for use with Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs), image preprocessing plays a crucial role in ensuring optimal performance. This article delves into essential image preprocessing techniques, focusing on resizing, aspect ratio considerations, padding, and alternatives, to help you understand and implement these techniques effectively.

1. Resizing: Resize images to a uniform size for consistent input to your CNN.
   • torchvision.transforms.Resize((224, 224))
2. Aspect Ratio: Decide whether to maintain aspect ratio during resizing.
   • Maintain: Prevent distortion, but may require padding.
     • torchvision.transforms.Resize(224, antialias=True)
   • Don't Maintain: Faster, but can distort object shapes.
     • torchvision.transforms.Resize((224, 224))
3. Padding: If maintaining aspect ratio, add padding to create square images.
   • Types: Constant (zeros), reflection, replication.
     • torchvision.transforms.Pad(padding=(10, 20), fill=0)
4. Padding Effects:
   • Large Padding: CNN might learn to ignore padded areas, potentially impacting accuracy.
   • Minimal Padding: Preferred to reduce the influence of padding.
5. Alternatives to Padding:
   • Cropping: Extract relevant regions, but might lose information.
     • torchvision.transforms.CenterCrop(224)
   • Non-Square Input: Some CNN architectures accept variable input sizes.
6. Experimentation: The best approach depends on your dataset and task. Try different combinations of resizing, padding, and cropping to find what works best.

This Python code demonstrates image transformations using torchvision, essential for preparing images for computer vision tasks. It covers resizing with and without maintaining aspect ratio, padding, cropping, and creating a transformation pipeline. The code provides examples of applying these transformations to individual images and integrating them with a dataset for training. It emphasizes the importance of choosing appropriate transformations based on the dataset and task, highlighting the trade-offs between maintaining aspect ratio and computational efficiency. The code serves as a practical guide for anyone working with image data in PyTorch, offering a starting point for building and experimenting with image processing pipelines.

import torch
from torchvision import transforms, datasets
from PIL import Image

# Load a sample image (replace with your image loading logic)
image = Image.open("sample_image.jpg")

# 1. Resizing to a uniform size
resize_transform = transforms.Resize((224, 224)) 
resized_image = resize_transform(image)

# 2. Resizing with aspect ratio considerations
# 2a. Maintain aspect ratio (requires padding later)
resize_maintain_aspect = transforms.Resize(224, antialias=True) 
resized_maintained_aspect_image = resize_maintain_aspect(image)

# 2b. Don't maintain aspect ratio (faster, but potential distortion)
resize_no_aspect = transforms.Resize((224, 224))
resized_no_aspect_image = resize_no_aspect(image)

# 3. Padding (if maintaining aspect ratio)
pad_transform = transforms.Pad(padding=(10, 20), fill=0) # Example padding
padded_image = pad_transform(resized_maintained_aspect_image) 

# 5. Alternatives to padding
# 5a. Cropping
crop_transform = transforms.CenterCrop(224)
cropped_image = crop_transform(image)

# Display images (replace with your image display logic)
resized_image.show()
resized_maintained_aspect_image.show()
resized_no_aspect_image.show()
padded_image.show()
cropped_image.show()

# --- Example of combining transforms in a pipeline ---
transform_pipeline = transforms.Compose([
    transforms.Resize(256, antialias=True),  # Resize larger dimension to 256
    transforms.CenterCrop(224),             # Crop center to 224x224
    transforms.ToTensor(),                  # Convert to PyTorch tensor
    transforms.Normalize(mean=[0.485, 0.456, 0.406], std=[0.229, 0.224, 0.225]) # Normalize
])

# Apply the pipeline to an image
transformed_image = transform_pipeline(image)

# --- Example of using transforms with a dataset ---
train_dataset = datasets.ImageFolder(
    'path/to/your/dataset', 
    transform=transform_pipeline
)

train_loader = torch.utils.data.DataLoader(train_dataset, batch_size=32, shuffle=True)

# ... (Rest of your training code) ... 

Explanation:

1. Import necessary libraries: torch, torchvision, and PIL.
2. Load an image: Replace "sample_image.jpg" with your image path.
3. Resizing:
   • transforms.Resize((224, 224)): Resizes the image to a fixed 224x224 size.
   • transforms.Resize(224, antialias=True): Resizes the smaller dimension to 224 while maintaining aspect ratio. Uses anti-aliasing for better quality.
4. Padding:
   • transforms.Pad(padding=(10, 20), fill=0): Adds 10 pixels of padding on the left/right and 20 pixels on the top/bottom, filled with zeros.
5. Cropping:
   • transforms.CenterCrop(224): Crops a 224x224 region from the center of the image.
6. Transform Pipeline:
   • transforms.Compose(): Chains multiple transformations together.
   • transforms.ToTensor(): Converts the PIL Image to a PyTorch tensor (required for CNN input).
   • transforms.Normalize(): Normalizes the image data using ImageNet's mean and standard deviation for better training.
7. Dataset Integration:
   • Demonstrates how to apply the transform pipeline to an ImageFolder dataset during training.

Key Points:

• Experimentation is crucial: The best combination of resizing, padding, and cropping depends on your specific dataset and task.
• Consider aspect ratio: Maintaining aspect ratio is generally recommended to avoid distorting object shapes, but it might require padding.
• Padding effects: Be mindful of the potential impact of padding on your model's learning.
• Alternatives to padding: Cropping or using CNN architectures that accept variable input sizes can be viable alternatives.

• Image Aspect Ratio: Understanding the dominant aspect ratios in your dataset (e.g., mostly square, wide, tall) can guide your choice between maintaining aspect ratio or not.
• Padding Value: When padding, fill=0 is common, but you can experiment with other values (e.g., image mean) depending on the task.
• Padding and Object Detection: For object detection tasks, large padding can be problematic as it can shift the relative positions of objects within the image.
• Centering Considerations: If you crop, ensure the important content is usually centered. If not, explore other cropping strategies (e.g., random cropping for data augmentation).
• Computational Cost: Resizing to a smaller size before padding or cropping can improve efficiency.
• Data Augmentation: Combine resizing, padding, and cropping with other data augmentation techniques (random cropping, flipping, rotation) to further improve model generalization.
• Pre-trained Models: If using pre-trained models, match the input size and preprocessing steps used during the model's training.
• Visualization: Visualize the effects of different preprocessing steps on your images to ensure they are being transformed as intended.
• Batch Processing: torchvision.transforms work seamlessly with data loaders for efficient batch processing during training.
• Custom Transforms: You can define your own custom transformation functions for more complex preprocessing needs.

This table summarizes key considerations for resizing and padding images before feeding them into a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN):

Key Takeaway: Experiment with different combinations of resizing, padding, and cropping techniques to determine the best preprocessing pipeline for your specific CNN application.

By understanding these techniques and through careful experimentation, you can optimize your image preprocessing pipeline to achieve the best possible results for your specific CNN task. Remember that the ideal approach depends heavily on your dataset's characteristics and the goals of your computer vision application. This guide provides a solid foundation for effectively preparing your image data for use with CNNs, ultimately contributing to improved model performance and more accurate results.

• CNN - Image Resizing VS Padding (keeping aspect ratio or not?) : r ... | Posted by u/yoniker - 3 votes and 2 comments
• machine learning - Image resizing and padding for CNN - Data ... | Apr 25, 2018 ... ... size after resizing them to some degree keeping ratio of width and height. ... not need to resize your images. TL;DR: yes, padding with ...
• You Might Be Resizing Your Images Incorrectly | Resizing images is a critical preprocessing step in computer vision. Principally, our machine learning models [https://models.roboflow.ai] train faster on smaller images. An input image that is twice as large requires our network to learn from four times as many pixels — and that time adds up. Moreover, many
• deep learning - How should we pad an image to be fed in a CNN ... | Aug 6, 2019 ... ... keep aspect ratio of the original image and retain it's information. ... I've more often seen image resizing than padding to be honest and tend to ...
• Best way to resize pictures for model training - Advanced (Part 1 v3 ... | What is the best way to resize pictures for the ConvLearner model? In the old version, there was a way to resize and it would create a new folder with the resized images, but I haven’t been able to figure out if that exists in v1. The reason I ask is because currently, my model I’m trying to train for classification takes a long time to run and I think it is because it is resizing the images every time instead of resizing them once at the beginning and using the small resized images for the re...
• How to resize and pad in a torchvision.transforms.Compose ... | I’m creating a torchvision.datasets.ImageFolder() data loader, adding torchvision.transforms steps for preprocessing each image inside my training/validation datasets. My main issue is that each image from training/validation has a different size (i.e.: 224x400, 150x300, 300x150, 224x224 etc). Since the classification model I’m training is very sensitive to the shape of the object in the image, I can’t make a simple torchvision.transforms.Resize(), I need to use padding to maintain the proporti...
• Non-Square images (Aspect ratio 16:9) for Training the YoloV8 ... | Search before asking I have searched the YOLOv8 issues and discussions and found no similar questions. Question Hi, I am trying to train YoloV8 on my custom dataset, in which the image sizes are 19...
• Is it possible to train ViT with different number of patches in every ... | Hi everyone. I have an image classification dataset consisting of non-square images with different sizes each of them. Training CNN, I used to rescale them to have 224 longer side and pad with zeros other side to make them square. Then I decided to use ViT and figured out zero padding drastically affect classification performance since lot of patches have only zeros. Random cropping and force rescaling to be square does not work because it is important to include all of the object in image a...
• Padding size should be less than the corresponding input ... | 🐛 Bug Reflective padding throws a runtime error when padding is bigger than one of the input sizes. RuntimeError: Argument #4: Padding size should be less than the corresponding input dimension, bu...