Solidity Error: Return Parameter Must Be "Memory"

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

In Solidity, understanding data location is crucial when working with complex data types like arrays, strings, and structs as function arguments or return values. You need to explicitly specify whether the data resides in memory or calldata to guide the EVM on data access.

In Solidity, you need to explicitly specify the data location for complex data types like arrays, strings, and structs when they are passed as function arguments or returned from functions. This is crucial for the EVM to understand where to read and write data.

Here's a breakdown:

1. Function Arguments:

• memory: Use memory for arguments that are passed to the function and modified temporarily within the function's scope. The data is copied to memory, changes are made to the copy, and the copy is discarded after the function call.

function myFunction(string memory _name) public pure {
    // ... modify _name ...
}

• calldata: Use calldata for read-only arguments, especially in external functions. Data in calldata is immutable and directly fetched from the transaction data, making it gas-efficient.

function myFunction(string calldata _name) external pure {
    // ... read from _name ...
}

2. Return Values:

• memory: Use memory for return values that are dynamically sized and need to be returned to the caller. The data is allocated in memory and returned to the caller.

function myFunction() public pure returns (string memory) {
    string memory result = "Hello";
    return result;
}

Common Errors:

• "Data location must be 'memory' or 'calldata' for parameter...": This error occurs when you pass a complex data type as a function argument without specifying its data location.

• "Data location must be 'memory' for return parameter...": This error occurs when you try to return a dynamically sized value without specifying memory.

Example:

function updateName(string memory _newName) public {
    // ... update a state variable with _newName ...
}

In this example, _newName is a string (complex type) passed as an argument. We use memory because we need a temporary copy of the string within the function.

This Solidity code defines a contract demonstrating data location usage in functions with strings and structs. It showcases using memory for temporary copies of function arguments and return values, especially for dynamically sized data. It also highlights calldata for read-only access to function arguments, improving gas efficiency by avoiding unnecessary data copying. The examples cover updating and retrieving strings, concatenating strings, getting string length, creating and returning structs, and accessing struct members, illustrating best practices for optimizing data handling in Solidity.

pragma solidity ^0.8.0;

contract DataLocationExample {

    // State variable to store a string
    string public name;

    // Function to update the name
    function updateName(string memory _newName) public {
        name = _newName;
    }

    // Function to get the name (read-only)
    function getName() public view returns (string memory) {
        return name;
    }

    // Function to concatenate two strings
    function concatenateStrings(string memory _str1, string memory _str2) public pure returns (string memory) {
        return string(abi.encodePacked(_str1, _str2));
    }

    // Function to get the length of a string (calldata for efficiency)
    function getStringLength(string calldata _str) external pure returns (uint) {
        return bytes(_str).length;
    }

    // Struct definition
    struct Person {
        string name;
        uint age;
    }

    // Function to create a Person struct and return it
    function createPerson(string memory _name, uint _age) public pure returns (Person memory) {
        Person memory newPerson = Person(_name, _age);
        return newPerson;
    }

    // Function to get the name from a Person struct (calldata for efficiency)
    function getPersonName(Person calldata _person) external pure returns (string memory) {
        return _person.name;
    }
}

Explanation:

1. updateName(string memory _newName):

   • _newName is a string passed as an argument.
   • We use memory because we need a temporary copy of the string to update the state variable name.

2. getName() returns (string memory):

   • The function returns a string.
   • We use memory because the returned string is dynamically sized.

3. concatenateStrings(string memory _str1, string memory _str2):

   • Both _str1 and _str2 are string arguments, and we need temporary copies for concatenation.
   • The function returns a dynamically sized string, so we use memory.

4. getStringLength(string calldata _str):

   • _str is a string argument, but we only need to read its length.
   • We use calldata for efficiency as it avoids copying the entire string to memory.

5. createPerson(string memory _name, uint _age):

   • _name is a string argument, requiring a temporary copy.
   • The function returns a Person struct, which is dynamically sized due to the string member. We use memory for both the struct and the _name argument.

6. getPersonName(Person calldata _person):

   • _person is a Person struct passed as an argument.
   • We only need to read the name member, so we use calldata for efficiency.

This example demonstrates the use of memory and calldata for different scenarios involving complex data types in Solidity. Remember to choose the appropriate data location based on whether you need to modify the data and whether you prioritize gas efficiency.

General:

• Clarity and Explicitness: Always specify data location for complex types. This improves code readability and helps avoid unexpected errors.
• Default for Elementary Types: Elementary types like uint, bool, address have a default data location depending on the context (function argument, return value, etc.). However, it's considered good practice to explicitly specify the data location even for elementary types for better code clarity.
• State Variables: State variables are stored permanently in the contract's storage and don't require a data location specifier when used within the contract.

Memory vs. Calldata:

• Gas Cost: Using calldata for read-only arguments is generally more gas-efficient than memory because it avoids copying data.
• Mutability: Data in memory can be modified within the function, while data in calldata is immutable.
• External Functions: You can only use calldata for function arguments in external functions.

Best Practices:

• Minimize Memory Usage: Excessive use of memory can lead to high gas costs, especially for large data structures. Use calldata whenever possible for read-only arguments.
• Data Visibility and Scope: Be mindful of the scope and visibility of data stored in memory. It's temporary and only exists within the function's execution.

Additional Points:

• storage Keyword: While not covered in the original article, it's worth mentioning the storage keyword, which is used to directly access and modify state variables.
• Solidity Version: Data location requirements and behavior might slightly differ between Solidity versions. Always refer to the documentation for the specific version you're using.

Example (Illustrating storage):

pragma solidity ^0.8.0;

contract StorageExample {

    // State variable (stored in storage)
    string[] public names;

    // Function to add a name to the array
    function addName(string memory _newName) public {
        names.push(_newName); // No need to specify 'storage' for 'names'
    }
}

Key Points:

• Explicit Data Location: Solidity requires explicit data location (memory or calldata) for complex data types (arrays, strings, structs) in function arguments and return values.
• Memory Management: memory allows data modification within the function scope but is less gas-efficient. calldata is read-only but more gas-efficient.
• Common Errors: Forgetting to specify data location leads to compilation errors.

Example:

function updateName(string memory _newName) public {
    // ... update a state variable with _newName ...
}

Here, _newName uses memory because it's a string (complex type) passed as an argument and potentially modified within the function.

Choosing the right data location is essential for efficient and error-free Solidity code. By understanding when to use memory for temporary copies and calldata for read-only access, you can optimize your smart contracts for gas efficiency and avoid common pitfalls. Remember to consult the Solidity documentation for specific data location rules and best practices relevant to your contract's complexity and version.

• Data location must be "memory" for return parameter in function, but ... | Oct 6, 2019 ... You should add memory keyword for string parameter, which was introduced in solidity version 0.5.0. As per the documentation: Explicit data ...
• solidity - TypeError: Data location must be "memory" for parameter in ... | Nov 23, 2018 ... TypeError: Data location must be "memory" for parameter in function, but none was given . I have no idea why this happened and i have not found ...
• When to use Storage vs. Memory vs. Calldata in Solidity | Learn about the different data locations in Solidity and when to them
• solidity - TypeError: Data location must be "storage" or "memory" for ... | Nov 29, 2018 ... TypeError: Data location must be "storage" or "memory" for parameter in function, but none was given · Ask Question. Asked 5 years, 11 months ...
• Solidity: Data location must be "memory" or "calldata" for return ... | Jun 21, 2021 ... Data location must be "memory" or "calldata" for return parameter in function, but none was given. My code: pragma solidity ^0.8.5; contract ...
• solidity - Data location must be “calldata” for parameter in external ... | Nov 5, 2019 ... Either function createNewUser (string memory _name, string memory _email, uint _aadhaar, string memory _sign) public.
• solidity - TypeError: Data location must be "memory" or "calldata" for ... | Dec 8, 2021 ... TypeError: Data location must be "memory" or "calldata" for parameter in function, but none was given · Ask Question. Asked 2 years, 11 months ...
• How To Fix 'Data Location Must Be Memory Or Calldata' - Cyfrin | Learn where the EVM can read and write data, what calldata, memory, and storage are, and the best practices to know when writing your solidity or Vyper smart contracts
• Why can't I return a dynamic array? : r/ethdev | Posted by u/pepeman931 - 14 votes and 8 comments