Kubernetes Pod Recreation Loop: Troubleshooting Guide

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

In Kubernetes, directly deleting pods managed by controllers like Deployments or ReplicaSets is usually ineffective as the controller will simply recreate them. To permanently stop these pods, you must target the controlling object itself. This article outlines the steps to identify and delete the relevant controller, effectively preventing pod recreation. Additionally, we'll explore scaling down controllers as a method for temporarily stopping pods without permanently deleting them.

Kubernetes pods are often managed by higher-level controllers like Deployments, ReplicaSets, StatefulSets, DaemonSets, or Jobs. When you delete a pod directly, these controllers automatically recreate them to maintain the desired state.

To stop pods from being recreated, you need to delete the controlling object:

1. Identify the controller:

   kubectl describe pod <pod-name>

   Look for the "Controlled By" field in the output.

2. Delete the controller:

   • Deployment: kubectl delete deployment <deployment-name>
   • ReplicaSet: kubectl delete replicaset <replicaset-name>
   • StatefulSet: kubectl delete statefulset <statefulset-name>
   • DaemonSet: kubectl delete daemonset <daemonset-name>
   • Job: kubectl delete job <job-name>

3. Alternatively, scale down the controller to zero:

   kubectl scale deployment <deployment-name> --replicas=0

   Replace deployment with the appropriate controller type.

Note: Deleting controllers will also delete all associated pods. If you only want to temporarily stop pods, scaling down to zero is a better option.

This code snippet demonstrates how to stop pods managed by a Kubernetes Deployment without deleting the Deployment configuration. It first shows how to identify the controller managing a pod using kubectl describe. Then, it demonstrates scaling down the Deployment to zero replicas to stop the pods. Finally, it provides an optional step to scale the Deployment back up, restarting the pods. The note emphasizes that this approach applies to other Kubernetes controllers like ReplicaSets, StatefulSets, DaemonSets, and Jobs.

Let's say you have a Deployment named "my-app" managing three pods. You want to stop these pods without deleting the entire Deployment configuration.

1. Identify the controller:

kubectl describe pod my-app-5f49d84757-xyz12

In the output, you'll see a section like this:

Controlled By:  Deployment/my-app

This confirms the pod is controlled by a Deployment named "my-app".

2. Scale down the Deployment to zero:

kubectl scale deployment my-app --replicas=0

This command instructs Kubernetes to scale down the "my-app" Deployment to zero replicas, effectively stopping all running pods without deleting the Deployment itself.

3. (Optional) Scale up the Deployment again:

When you're ready to restart the pods, you can scale the Deployment back up:

kubectl scale deployment my-app --replicas=3

This will create three new pods based on the Deployment's configuration.

Note: This example uses a Deployment, but the same principle applies to other controllers like ReplicaSets, StatefulSets, DaemonSets, and Jobs. Simply replace "deployment" with the appropriate controller type in the commands.

• Understanding Controllers: It's crucial to grasp that controllers are the backbone of Kubernetes' self-healing capabilities. They continuously monitor and reconcile the actual state of your application (running pods) with the desired state defined in their configuration.
• kubectl Alternatives: While the command line is powerful, tools like Kubernetes Dashboard or Rancher provide graphical interfaces to manage deployments and other resources, simplifying these tasks for visual learners.
• Resource Limits: When scaling down a controller to zero, remember that the associated resources (CPU, memory) are freed up. This can be helpful for managing resource consumption in your cluster.
• Graceful Termination: When scaling down or deleting controllers, Kubernetes attempts to terminate pods gracefully. Ensure your applications handle SIGTERM signals properly for a clean shutdown.
• Debugging: If pods are being recreated unexpectedly, check the controller's events for clues: kubectl describe <controller-type> <controller-name>. Look for errors or warnings that might explain the behavior.
• Namespaces: Remember to specify the correct namespace when working with pods and controllers. Use the -n <namespace> flag with kubectl commands.
• Production Considerations: Avoid directly deleting pods in production unless absolutely necessary. Scaling down the controller is generally a safer approach.
• Alternatives to Deletion: Consider using tools like kubectl cordon and kubectl drain to safely evict pods from a node for maintenance without triggering recreation by the controller.

Kubernetes controllers (Deployments, ReplicaSets, etc.) automatically recreate deleted pods to maintain the desired application state. To stop this behavior:

1. Identify the Controller:

• Use kubectl describe pod <pod-name> and check the "Controlled By" field.

2. Permanently Stop Pods (Delete Controller):

• Deployment: kubectl delete deployment <deployment-name>
• ReplicaSet: kubectl delete replicaset <replicaset-name>
• StatefulSet: kubectl delete statefulset <statefulset-name>
• DaemonSet: kubectl delete daemonset <daemonset-name>
• Job: kubectl delete job <job-name>

3. Temporarily Stop Pods (Scale Down):

• kubectl scale <controller-type> <controller-name> --replicas=0
  • Replace <controller-type> and <controller-name> accordingly.

Important: Deleting a controller removes all associated pods permanently. Scaling down to zero is preferred for temporary stopping.

Understanding how to manage pods through their controllers is essential for controlling your Kubernetes applications. By identifying and then deleting or scaling down the appropriate controller, you can prevent pods from being automatically recreated, giving you greater control over your deployments and resource management. Remember to proceed with caution in production environments, opting for scaling down instead of deletion when possible to avoid unintended service disruptions. Familiarizing yourself with these concepts will significantly enhance your ability to manage and troubleshoot your Kubernetes deployments effectively.

• kubernetes pods getting recreated? | Jhooq | Oct 22, 2021 ... kubernetes pods getting recreated? · Run kubectl get to list all the resources running in the cluster · Delete replica set - If the replica set is ...
• kubectl - kubernetes pod keeps restarting after it was deleted - Stack ... | Oct 19, 2021 ... After I deleted those services, the pods did not get recreated again. I still think this is not a good solution to the problem ("Just delete ...
• Kubernetes pod gets recreated when deleted | by Harold Finch ... | When a Kubernetes pod gets recreated after being deleted, it is usually due to the fact that it is managed by a higher-level controller…
• kubectl - How could I find the Kubernetes Pod restart reasons ... | May 16, 2021 ... When I say Pod recreated, it is getting deleted and created freshly ... If Pod's Node is not available, Kubernetes recreates the Pods in other ...
• (CronJob) PODs are deleted immediately when a job fails - General ... | I have a question regarding the CronJob resource. In the spec I have set both successfulJobsHistoryLimit and failedJobsHistoryLimit to 3 and backoffLimit=0 to basically always keep history of minimum last 3 jobs and not retry a job if it fails for any reason (e.g. OOM). This works, but what I am seeing is that the PODs are terminated (deleted) immediately as they fail even though the jobs are kept according to the history limits. According to the Job docs: “When a Job completes, no more Pods a...
• google cloud platform - Why do pods on a node that was recreated ... | Feb 22, 2019 ... ... getting, GKE version, etc. By the way, when a node gets preempted, the nodes gets deleted and recreated, so a reset could not have the same ...
• When kubernetes deployment is deleted, ReplicaSets are not being ... | I am using Kubernetes version: 1.25.8. I have a yaml to create a deployment with 2 pods of nginx. When I apply the yaml (kubecl apply), it creates the below resources: 1 Deployment 1 ReplicaSet 2 Pods. When I delete the yaml (kubectl delete), deployment is deleted but replicaSet and pods are still there. Note: I also tried spec.revisionHistoryLimit but it works only when I update the deployment with some change (for example nginx version) but on deployment deletion, replicaSets and pods ar...
• Pod Redundancy in Kubernetes or Why Deleted Pods Get Recreated | Learn about redundancy at the pod level in Kubernetes and find out why pods might get recreated even after manual deletion.
• Pods are getting recreated due to the fargate node in EKS | AWS re ... | Hello Team,

I am running my workload in EKS Cluster using Fargate node and it runs successfully but intermittently I see my fargate nodes are recreated from AWS so the Kubernetes statefulset and d...