Terraform tags vs tags_all: Understanding the Difference

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

In Terraform, managing resource tags effectively is crucial for organization, automation, and cost allocation. While both tags and tags_all attributes deal with tags, understanding their distinct purposes and use cases is essential for writing efficient and predictable infrastructure code.

In Terraform, tags and tags_all are used for managing resource tags, but they serve different purposes:

tags: This attribute represents resource-specific tags defined directly within the resource block.

resource "aws_instance" "example" {
  # ... other configurations ...

  tags = {
    Name = "My Instance"
    Environment = "Production"
  }
}

tags_all: This attribute provides a read-only view of all tags applied to a resource, including: - Tags defined in the resource's tags attribute. - Default tags inherited from provider configurations or module defaults.

output "instance_tags" {
  value = aws_instance.example.tags_all
}

Key Differences:

• Mutability: tags is mutable, allowing you to add, modify, or delete tags directly. tags_all is read-only and reflects the combined set of tags.
• Scope: tags are specific to the resource block where they are defined. tags_all provides a comprehensive view, including inherited tags.

Use Cases:

• Use tags to define resource-specific tags that are unique to that instance.
• Use tags_all to retrieve and reference all tags associated with a resource, including inherited ones.

Example:

# Provider-level default tags
provider "aws" {
  default_tags {
    tags = {
      Owner = "Operations"
    }
  }
}

# Resource with specific and inherited tags
resource "aws_instance" "example" {
  # ... other configurations ...

  tags = {
    Name = "My Instance"
    Environment = "Production"
  }
}

# Outputting all tags
output "instance_tags" {
  value = aws_instance.example.tags_all
}

In this example, aws_instance.example.tags_all would output:

{
  "Name" = "My Instance"
  "Environment" = "Production"
  "Owner" = "Operations" 
}

This Terraform code configures an AWS provider with default tags for Owner and CostCenter. It then defines an EC2 instance resource with specific tags for Name and Environment. The code outputs all tags associated with the instance, including both explicitly defined and inherited default tags.

# Configure the AWS Provider with default tags
terraform {
  required_providers {
    aws = {
      source  = "hashicorp/aws"
      version = "~> 4.0"
    }
  }
}

provider "aws" {
  region = "us-west-2" # Replace with your desired region

  default_tags {
    tags = {
      Owner       = "Operations"
      CostCenter = "IT001"
    }
  }
}

# Define an AWS EC2 Instance resource with specific tags
resource "aws_instance" "example" {
  ami           = "ami-0c55b159c9e67027c" # Replace with your desired AMI ID
  instance_type = "t2.micro"

  tags = {
    Name        = "My Instance"
    Environment = "Production"
  }
}

# Output all tags associated with the EC2 instance (including inherited tags)
output "instance_tags" {
  value = aws_instance.example.tags_all
}

Explanation:

1. Provider Configuration:

   • We define default tags at the provider level using provider "aws" {} and the default_tags block. These tags will be applied to all resources created within this scope unless overridden.

2. Resource Definition:

   • An EC2 instance (aws_instance.example) is defined with its own set of tags using the tags attribute.

3. Outputting Tags:

   • The output "instance_tags" block uses aws_instance.example.tags_all to retrieve and display all tags associated with the instance. This will include both the tags defined directly within the resource block (Name and Environment) and the default tags inherited from the provider configuration (Owner and CostCenter).

Running the Code:

1. Save the code as a .tf file (e.g., tags_example.tf).
2. Run terraform init to initialize the working directory.
3. Run terraform apply to create the resources.

After applying, the output will show the combined set of tags:

instance_tags = {
  "CostCenter" = "IT001"
  "Environment" = "Production"
  "Name" = "My Instance"
  "Owner" = "Operations"
}

This demonstrates how tags and tags_all work in Terraform, allowing you to manage resource tags effectively and maintain consistency across your infrastructure.

• Importance of Tags: Tags are crucial for organizing, managing, and tracking costs of your cloud resources. They provide a flexible way to categorize and search for resources based on various criteria like environment, project, or owner.

• Tagging Best Practices:

  • Consistency: Use a consistent naming convention for tags across your infrastructure.
  • Meaningful Names: Choose tag names that clearly describe the purpose or value of the tag.
  • Automation: Leverage Terraform's capabilities to automate tag creation and management.

• tags vs. tags_all in Code:

  • When defining tags within a resource block, use the tags attribute.
  • When referencing or outputting all tags associated with a resource, use the tags_all attribute.

• Troubleshooting Tagging Issues:

  • If you encounter issues with tags not being applied correctly, double-check for typos in tag names or values.
  • Ensure that default tags defined at the provider level are intended for all resources within that scope.

• Additional Notes:

  • The availability of the tags_all attribute might vary slightly depending on the specific Terraform provider and resource type.
  • Refer to the official documentation of the Terraform provider for the most up-to-date information on tag management.

By understanding the differences between tags and tags_all, Terraform users can implement a robust and scalable tagging strategy, improving resource organization, automation, and cost management in their infrastructure as code.

• Tags and tags_all: removes tags - AWS - HashiCorp Discuss | Hello, i noticed that every time the code runs it either removes all tags or adds all of them. Not sure why. the simplified code is like this: locals { base_tags = { Client = var.Client_abbr ... } } ... resource "aws_instance" "this" { for_each = var.vms ... tags_all = merge( { ... ProductFamily = ${each.value.tag_productfamily} ... }, local.base_tags ) } The reason for using tags_all is to add provider level tags should I h...
• Terraform: what's the difference between "tags" and "tags_all ... | Mar 28, 2022 ... In Terraform, you can define tags in top-level. tags_all is basically individual resource tags + top level tags. For example;
• Configure default tags for AWS resources | Terraform | HashiCorp ... | The tags attribute represents the resource-specific tags in Terraform state, while tags_all is the total of the resource tags and the default tags specified ...
• tags_all overwriting tags for a resource : r/Terraform | Posted by u/New-Communication635 - 1 vote and 1 comment
• default_tags always shows an update · Issue #18311 · hashicorp ... | Description I have been looking forward to the default tagging support and tested it on a project yesterday which uses https://github.com/terraform-aws-modules/terraform-aws-vpc/ — this immediately...
• How to tag AWS resources in Terraform effectively | by Leslie ... | Let’s take a look at how tags and default_tags work in the AWS Terraform provider — with examples. Tags are a great way to identify cost…
• How to Use Tags in Terraform? [Overview & Examples] | Learn about Terraform tags and the different use cases they have. See default tags, ignoring changes, and merging examples.
• dynamic tags broken (an invalid new value for .tags_all: new ... | This used to work at some point, but is broken now. e.g. locals { ... long_appname = element(split("/", path.cwd), length(split("/", path.cwd)) - 2) short_appname = element(split("_", local.long_ap...
• Terraform AWS Provider Resource Tagging | Guides | hashicorp ... | To access all the tags applied to the VPC resource, use the read-only attribute tags_all , e.g., aws_vpc.example.tags_all . New Multi-language provider docs.