Kubernetes External IP Pending: Troubleshooting Guide

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

If you're seeing a "pending" external IP for a Kubernetes LoadBalancer service, it means your cluster is struggling to get a public IP address to route traffic to your application. This article will guide you through the common reasons behind this issue and provide troubleshooting steps to get your services back online.

A "pending" external IP for a Kubernetes LoadBalancer service means your cluster can't acquire an external IP address to route traffic to your service. Here's a breakdown of why this happens and how to troubleshoot it:

1. Cloud Provider Integration:

• LoadBalancer services rely on your cloud provider (AWS, GCP, Azure) to provision and assign external IPs.
• Check: Ensure your cluster is running on a supported cloud platform and not in a local environment like minikube or kind.

2. Insufficient Permissions:

• Your cloud provider account might lack permissions to create load balancer resources.
• Check: Review your cloud provider IAM roles and ensure they have the necessary permissions to manage network resources.

3. Resource Quotas:

• Cloud providers often have quotas on resources like load balancers. You might have hit your limit.
• Check: Inspect your cloud console for resource quotas related to networking and load balancers.

4. Cloud Provider Issues:

• Occasionally, cloud provider services can experience temporary outages or issues.
• Check: Visit your cloud provider's status page to check for any reported problems related to networking or load balancing.

5. Misconfigured Service Definition:

• Errors in your Kubernetes service YAML file can prevent the load balancer from being created correctly.
• Check:
  • Verify the type: LoadBalancer is correctly specified.
  • Ensure the ports section accurately maps container ports to service ports.

6. Network Connectivity:

• Network connectivity problems between your cluster and the cloud provider's network can cause issues.
• Check:
  • Ensure your cluster nodes have proper network access to communicate with the cloud provider's APIs.

Example: Checking Service Status

kubectl describe service <your-service-name>

Look for events or messages in the output that might provide clues about the "pending" status.

Important: If you're not using a supported cloud provider, you'll need to explore alternative ways to expose your services externally, such as NodePort or Ingress.

This guide helps troubleshoot Kubernetes LoadBalancer services stuck in "pending" state. It covers verifying cloud provider compatibility, checking permissions for load balancer creation, inspecting resource quotas, monitoring cloud provider service status, examining the service definition for correctness, testing network connectivity from the cluster to the cloud provider, and finally, checking service status and events for error messages. It also provides an example event message indicating insufficient permissions. If you are not using a supported cloud provider, consider alternatives like NodePort or Ingress.

This example demonstrates how to troubleshoot a "pending" external IP for a Kubernetes LoadBalancer service.

1. Verify Cloud Provider and Environment:

• Ensure your cluster is running on a supported cloud platform (AWS, GCP, Azure) and not in a local environment like minikube or kind.

2. Check Cloud Provider Permissions:

• AWS: Verify your IAM role has permissions like ec2:DescribeInstances, ec2:CreateLoadBalancer, etc.
• GCP: Ensure your service account has roles like compute.instanceAdmin.v1, compute.networkAdmin, etc.
• Azure: Check your Azure RBAC role assignments for permissions like Microsoft.Network/loadBalancers/*.

3. Inspect Resource Quotas:

• AWS: Go to the EC2 console, navigate to "Load Balancers" and check the "Quota Details" section.
• GCP: In the GCP console, go to "IAM & Admin" -> "Quotas" and filter for "Load Balancing".
• Azure: Navigate to your subscription in the Azure portal, go to "Usage + quotas" and check for "Network" related quotas.

4. Monitor Cloud Provider Status:

• AWS: Check the AWS Service Health Dashboard: https://status.aws.amazon.com/
• GCP: Visit the Google Cloud Status Dashboard: https://status.cloud.google.com/
• Azure: Go to the Azure Status page: https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/status/

5. Examine Service Definition:

apiVersion: v1
kind: Service
metadata:
  name: my-service
spec:
  type: LoadBalancer
  ports:
  - port: 80
    targetPort: 8080
  selector:
    app: my-app

• Ensure type: LoadBalancer is present.
• Verify ports correctly map container ports to service ports.

6. Test Network Connectivity:

• From a cluster node, try to reach your cloud provider's API endpoint. For example:
  • AWS: curl https://ec2.amazonaws.com
  • GCP: curl https://www.googleapis.com/discovery/v1/apis/compute/v1/rest
  • Azure: curl https://management.azure.com/

7. Check Service Status and Events:

kubectl describe service my-service

Look for events or messages indicating the cause of the "pending" status.

Example Event Message (AWS):

Events:
  Type     Reason                        Age   From                Message
  ----     ------                        ----  ----                -------
  Warning  CreatingLoadBalancerFailed  5m    service-controller  Error creating load balancer (will retry): failed to ensure load balancer for service default/my-service: error creating load balancer: operation not permitted

This message suggests insufficient IAM permissions to create load balancers.

Remember: If you're not using a supported cloud provider, explore alternatives like NodePort or Ingress to expose your services externally.

• Common Culprit: Insufficient permissions are a frequent cause. Double-check your cloud provider IAM roles and policies.
• Event Logs are Key: The kubectl describe service <service-name> command is your friend. Carefully examine the events for specific error messages.
• Think Beyond Permissions: While permissions are common, don't neglect resource quotas, especially if you've deployed many services.
• Cloud Provider Quirks: Each cloud provider has its own nuances. Familiarize yourself with their load balancer documentation and specific troubleshooting tips.
• Beyond the "Pending" State: Even if the external IP is assigned, ensure traffic is flowing correctly. Use tools like curl or web browsers to test connectivity.
• Consider Alternatives: If you're not using a supported cloud provider or need more control, explore NodePort or Ingress for exposing your services.
• Debugging Network Connectivity: If suspecting network issues, use tools like ping, traceroute, or nslookup to pinpoint the problem.
• Community Support: Online forums and communities are valuable resources. Provide detailed information about your setup and the steps you've taken when seeking help.

Checking Service Status:

kubectl describe service <your-service-name>

Examine the output for events or messages that might explain the "pending" status.

Note: If you're not using a supported cloud provider, explore alternative service exposure methods like NodePort or Ingress.

A "pending" external IP for your Kubernetes LoadBalancer service indicates a roadblock in getting traffic to your application. By systematically investigating cloud provider integration, permissions, resource quotas, potential cloud provider issues, and the configuration of your service definition, you can pinpoint the root cause. Remember to leverage the kubectl describe service <service-name> command to gain insights from events and status messages. If you're not utilizing a supported cloud provider, exploring alternative methods like NodePort or Ingress for service exposure is necessary. With careful troubleshooting and a structured approach, you can resolve this issue and ensure your applications are accessible.

• Load Balancer Services Always Show EXTERNAL-IP Pending ... | Asking for help? Comment out what you need so we can get more information to help you! Cluster information: Kubernetes version: 1.17 Cloud being used: (put bare-metal if not on a public cloud) bare-metal Installation method: Host OS: Centos 7 CNI and version: Kamel CRI and version: I am trying to get a load balancer service to show a non-pending EXTERNAL-IP. I’ve been working with the “kubia” services found in the “Kamel In Action” book. In the following we see my service pending. [...
• Kubernetes LoadBalancer IP Stuck in Pending | by Paul Boone ... | The Kubernetes Service object exposes an application’s network interface, enabling clients to invoke the application via TCP or UDP. The…
• Exposing an External IP Address to Access an Application in a ... | This page shows how to create a Kubernetes Service object that exposes an external IP address. Before you begin Install kubectl. Use a cloud provider like Google Kubernetes Engine or Amazon Web Services to create a Kubernetes cluster. This tutorial creates an external load balancer, which requires a cloud provider. Configure kubectl to communicate with your Kubernetes API server. For instructions, see the documentation for your cloud provider. Objectives Run five instances of a Hello World application.
• Kubernetes service external ip is pending. : r/kubernetes | Posted by u/gnk714 - 6 votes and 7 comments
• Kubernetes service external ip pending | by Harold Finch | Medium | When a Kubernetes service’s external IP is stuck in a “pending” state, it indicates that Kubernetes is unable to assign an external IP…
• microk8s service external-ip stuck on . loadBalancer not ... | Posted by u/queBurro - 3 votes and 6 comments
• Kubernetes Load balanced services are sometimes marked as ... | I am using the Docker Desktop k8s environment to apply and delete k8s resources over and over, as part of my project's test automation. One of these resources is a load balanced service. Something ...
• Azure Kubernetes Service Error – LoadBalancer type service ... | Last week I was working on my Azure Kubernetes Service cluster when I ran into a rather odd issue. I’d created a service with a type of LoadBalancer in order to get an external IP to connect …
• Load balancer external-ip pending · Issue #411 · kubernetes-sigs ... | I deploy the same deployment and expose it via the same kubectl expose deployment supervisor-deployment --type=LoadBalancer --name=supervisor-service command, in docker-desktop, a service is create...