Evaluating Homography Matrices: Accuracy and Validity

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

Homography estimation, a fundamental technique in computer vision, often requires evaluation to ensure its accuracy. This article outlines key steps to assess the quality of a computed homography matrix. We'll cover reprojection error, inlier ratio analysis, visual inspection, and condition number examination as reliable indicators of homography performance.

1. Reprojection: Use the computed homography matrix to reproject the points from the first image onto the second image.

   # Assuming 'H' is your homography matrix and 'pts1' are points in the first image
   pts2_projected = cv2.perspectiveTransform(pts1.reshape(-1, 1, 2), H) 

2. Euclidean Distance: Calculate the Euclidean distance between the reprojected points and the actual corresponding points in the second image.

   distances = np.linalg.norm(pts2_projected - pts2.reshape(-1, 1, 2), axis=2)

3. Thresholding: Set a threshold for the acceptable distance. Points with distances exceeding this threshold indicate a poor homography.

   threshold = 5  # Example threshold, adjust based on your application
   inliers = distances < threshold

4. Inlier Ratio: A high ratio of inliers (points within the threshold) suggests a good homography.

   inlier_ratio = np.sum(inliers) / len(inliers)
   if inlier_ratio > 0.8:  # Example threshold
       print("Homography is likely acceptable")

5. Visual Inspection: Visualize the reprojected points on the second image to verify alignment. Large deviations indicate problems.

6. Condition Number: A very high condition number of the homography matrix can indicate instability.

   condition_number = np.linalg.cond(H)

Remember: The thresholds for distance, inlier ratio, and condition number are application-specific and may require adjustment.

This Python code demonstrates homography estimation and evaluation between two images. It assumes you have already performed feature matching and obtained corresponding points. The code computes the homography matrix using RANSAC, projects points from the first image to the second, and calculates the inlier ratio based on reprojection error. It also includes optional visual inspection of inliers and outliers and checks the condition number of the homography matrix for stability assessment.

import cv2
import numpy as np

# Load the two images
img1 = cv2.imread('image1.jpg')
img2 = cv2.imread('image2.jpg')

# ... (Your feature detection and matching code here) ...

# Assume you have found corresponding points:
# pts1: Points in the first image (NumPy array of shape (N, 2))
# pts2: Corresponding points in the second image (NumPy array of shape (N, 2))

# 1. Compute Homography
H, _ = cv2.findHomography(pts1, pts2, cv2.RANSAC, 5.0)  # Use RANSAC for robustness

# 2. Reprojection
pts2_projected = cv2.perspectiveTransform(pts1.reshape(-1, 1, 2), H)

# 3. Euclidean Distance
distances = np.linalg.norm(pts2_projected - pts2.reshape(-1, 1, 2), axis=2)

# 4. Thresholding
threshold = 5  # Adjust based on your application
inliers = distances < threshold

# 5. Inlier Ratio
inlier_ratio = np.sum(inliers) / len(inliers)
print(f"Inlier Ratio: {inlier_ratio:.2f}")
if inlier_ratio > 0.8:  # Adjust threshold as needed
    print("Homography is likely acceptable")

# 6. Visual Inspection (Optional but recommended)
for pt1, pt2, inlier in zip(pts1, pts2, inliers):
    if inlier:
        color = (0, 255, 0)  # Green for inliers
    else:
        color = (0, 0, 255)  # Red for outliers
    pt1 = tuple(map(int, pt1))
    pt2 = tuple(map(int, pt2))
    cv2.circle(img2, pt2, 5, color, -1)  # Draw circles on the second image

cv2.imshow("Image 2 with Reprojected Points", img2)
cv2.waitKey(0)
cv2.destroyAllWindows()

# 7. Condition Number
condition_number = np.linalg.cond(H)
print(f"Condition Number: {condition_number:.2f}")
if condition_number > 1e6:  # Adjust threshold as needed
    print("Warning: High condition number, homography might be unstable!")

Explanation:

1. Load Images and Find Matches: This part is assumed to be done. You'll need to use feature detection (like SIFT, ORB) and matching techniques.
2. Compute Homography: cv2.findHomography calculates the homography matrix H using the matched points. RANSAC is used to handle outliers.
3. Reprojection: The code projects points from img1 to img2 using the homography.
4. Euclidean Distance: Calculates the distance between the reprojected points and the actual matching points in img2.
5. Thresholding and Inlier Ratio: Points with distances below the threshold are considered inliers. A high inlier ratio indicates a good homography.
6. Visual Inspection: (Optional) This code draws the reprojected points on img2. Green dots are inliers, and red dots are outliers. This visual check helps assess the homography quality.
7. Condition Number: A high condition number of the homography matrix can indicate instability.

Important:

• Replace 'image1.jpg' and 'image2.jpg' with your image file paths.
• Adjust thresholds (threshold, inlier_ratio, condition_number) based on your specific application and image characteristics.
• The visual inspection part is commented out but highly recommended for understanding the homography's accuracy.

Reprojection and Euclidean Distance:

• Purpose: These steps quantify how well the homography maps points from the first image to the second.
• Ideal Scenario: Reprojected points should perfectly overlap with their corresponding points in the second image (i.e., zero Euclidean distance).
• Real-World: Due to noise, lens distortion, and imperfect feature matching, there will always be some reprojection error.

Thresholding and Inlier Ratio:

• Threshold Selection: This is crucial and depends on your application's sensitivity to misalignment. A smaller threshold enforces stricter alignment.
• Inlier Ratio Interpretation:
  • High Ratio (e.g., > 0.8): The homography is likely accurate. Most points align well.
  • Low Ratio: The homography might be unreliable. Consider:
    • Improving feature matching.
    • Using more robust homography estimation techniques (e.g., RANSAC with different parameters).

Visual Inspection:

• Importance: Essential for qualitative assessment. Sometimes, even a good inlier ratio might mask localized misalignments.
• How to Inspect:
  • Overlay reprojected points on the second image.
  • Look for systematic deviations or regions where points don't align well.

Condition Number:

• Linear Algebra Concept: Measures the sensitivity of the homography matrix to small changes in input data.
• High Condition Number: Indicates an unstable homography. Small errors in input points can lead to large errors in the transformation.
• Causes of High Condition Number:
  • Points lying close to a line or plane (degenerate configurations).
  • Poorly distributed feature points.

Additional Considerations:

• Image Content: Homography estimation works best on planar or near-planar scenes.
• Distortion Correction: For accurate results, consider undistorting images if significant lens distortion is present.
• Alternative Metrics: Other metrics like root mean square error (RMSE) of reprojection errors can also be used.

This article outlines a method for evaluating the quality of a computed homography matrix, which describes the transformation between two images.

The process involves:

1. Reprojection: Using the homography matrix (H), points from the first image (pts1) are projected onto the second image (pts2_projected).

2. Distance Calculation: The Euclidean distance between the reprojected points and their corresponding points in the second image (pts2) is calculated.

3. Thresholding: A threshold is set to determine acceptable deviations. Points exceeding this threshold are considered outliers, indicating potential issues with the homography.

4. Inlier Ratio: The ratio of inliers (points within the threshold) to the total number of points provides a measure of the homography's accuracy. A higher ratio suggests a better fit.

5. Visual Inspection: Visualizing the reprojected points on the second image helps identify significant misalignments.

6. Condition Number: A high condition number of the homography matrix can indicate instability and potential inaccuracies.

Key Points:

• Thresholds for distance, inlier ratio, and condition number are application-dependent and require adjustment based on specific needs.
• This method provides a quantitative and qualitative assessment of the homography matrix, aiding in determining its reliability for image alignment and other applications.

By analyzing the reprojection error, inlier ratio, visual alignment, and condition number, we can effectively evaluate the quality and reliability of a computed homography matrix. These steps are crucial for ensuring accurate image alignment and successful application of homography-based techniques in computer vision tasks. Remember that thresholds and parameters should be adjusted based on the specific application and image characteristics for optimal results.

• linear algebra - How to check if an image to image homography is ... | Mar 31, 2021 ... The input image is about 512x512 pixels so these translations are not so unreasonable. But the matrix is ill-conditioned (condition number is ~ ...
• opencv - How to check if obtained homography matrix is good ... | Feb 19, 2013 ... I obtain a homography matrix by calling cv::findHomography from a set of points. I need to check whether it's relevant or not.
• Validate matrices to be decomposable to TRS · Issue #21 · gltf-rs/gltf ... | From the 2.0 draft spec: Matrices must be decomposable to TRS. This implies that transformation matrices cannot skew or shear. (Source) I think it would be good to check the matrices on load. Perha...
• computer vision - Detecting garbage homographies from ... | Jun 10, 2012 ... How can you tell if a homography matrix is acceptable or not? 6 · calculating the destination points for OpenCV's findHomography · 18 · How to ...
• computer vision - Why do we need 4 points for homography but 7/8 ... | Apr 17, 2017 ... I also understand that both homography and fundamental matrices ... Homography valid for patch within the image but not the entire image?
• 3d - Non unique homography matrices for planar decomposition ... | Dec 12, 2017 ... Page 6 of that text writes: cTd = [cRd ctd] [ 0 1 ]. so the text at that point appears to be dealing with an affine transformation only, ...
• corner pin adjustement of plane/quad with videotexture? - Jitter ... | Before I twist my brain yet another turn:

I am trying to achieve something which seems simple in environments like quartz composer/vdmx...

• Accurate Translational Velocity - Luxonis Forum | Hey! I'm looking for a highly accurate solution to get the translational velocity from a standard OAK-D sensor. I know IMUs tend to only be so accurate wher...
• A Hugin cpfind alternative / project cleanup tool for tiling - www ... | Nov 20, 2023 ... I was having difficulty telling if the pairs were real or not ... If all of the homography matrices are consistent - that is to say ...