Access Counted Resource Attributes in Terraform

• Introduction
• Step-by-Step Guide
• Code Example
• Additional Notes
• Summary
• Conclusion
• References

Terraform, a powerful infrastructure-as-code tool, can sometimes encounter roadblocks known as "cycles" during the planning stage. These cycles occur when resources in your configuration have circular dependencies, leaving Terraform unable to determine a safe order for creation or destruction. This article will guide you through identifying, understanding, and resolving Terraform cycles, ensuring your infrastructure deployments proceed smoothly.

Let's break down how to troubleshoot Terraform cycles and understand the concepts involved.

Understanding Terraform Cycles

Terraform uses your configuration files to plan infrastructure changes. A "cycle" occurs when resources depend on each other in a way that creates a circular dependency. Terraform can't determine a starting point for creation or destruction.

Example Scenario

Imagine you're defining two AWS Lambda functions:

locals {
  lambda_functions = {
    function_a = { 
      # ... function configuration
      depends_on = [aws_cloudwatch_log_group.function_b_log_group] 
    }
    function_b = { 
      # ... function configuration
      depends_on = [aws_cloudwatch_log_group.function_a_log_group] 
    }
  }
}

resource "aws_cloudwatch_log_group" "function_a_log_group" {
  # ... log group configuration for function_a
}

resource "aws_cloudwatch_log_group" "function_b_log_group" {
  # ... log group configuration for function_b
}

The Problem: function_a needs function_b_log_group to exist, but function_b also needs function_a_log_group. This is a circular dependency.

Resolving Cycles

1. Review depends_on: Carefully examine any explicit dependencies you've set using depends_on. Ensure they are truly necessary and don't create circular relationships.

2. Implicit Dependencies: Terraform often infers dependencies. For instance, if a Lambda function references a CloudWatch Log Group by ID, that's an implicit dependency.

3. Break the Cycle:

   • Reorganize: If possible, restructure your code to eliminate the circular relationship. Can you create one resource without depending on the other first?
   • Temporary Resources: In some cases, you might introduce a temporary resource to break the cycle. For example, you could create a default log group, then update your functions to use the correct log groups in a later step.

Additional Tips

• Terraform Graph: Visualize your infrastructure dependencies using terraform graph. This can help you spot cycles more easily.
• Modules: Modules encourage code organization and can help prevent cycles by enforcing clearer boundaries between resources.
• Variable Usage: Ensure variables are used consistently and don't introduce unexpected dependencies.

Key Takeaways

• Cycles prevent Terraform from creating or destroying resources.
• Carefully analyze depends_on and implicit dependencies.
• Restructure your code or use temporary resources to break cycles.

The Terraform code defines two Lambda functions and their corresponding CloudWatch log groups. It demonstrates a circular dependency scenario where each function depends on the other's log group, resulting in a cycle. The solution involves removing the explicit 'depends_on' blocks from the Lambda function definitions, as Terraform implicitly understands the dependency between a Lambda function and its log group. By removing the unnecessary dependency, the code successfully breaks the cycle. The code also suggests using 'terraform graph' to visualize and understand infrastructure dependencies.

This example illustrates the cycle scenario described in the article and provides a solution to break the dependency.

File: main.tf

locals {
  lambda_functions = {
    function_a = { 
      # ... function configuration
    }
    function_b = { 
      # ... function configuration
    }
  }
}

# Create CloudWatch Log Groups
resource "aws_cloudwatch_log_group" "function_a_log_group" {
  name = "/aws/lambda/${local.lambda_functions.function_a.name}"
  # ... other log group configurations
}

resource "aws_cloudwatch_log_group" "function_b_log_group" {
  name = "/aws/lambda/${local.lambda_functions.function_b.name}"
  # ... other log group configurations
}

# Create Lambda Functions with dependencies (This will cause a cycle!)
# resource "aws_lambda_function" "function_a" {
#   function_name = local.lambda_functions.function_a.name
#   # ... other function configurations
#   depends_on = [aws_cloudwatch_log_group.function_b_log_group] 
# }

# resource "aws_lambda_function" "function_b" {
#   function_name = local.lambda_functions.function_b.name
#   # ... other function configurations
#   depends_on = [aws_cloudwatch_log_group.function_a_log_group] 
# }

# Solution: Remove the circular dependency
resource "aws_lambda_function" "function_a" {
  function_name = local.lambda_functions.function_a.name
  # ... other function configurations
}

resource "aws_lambda_function" "function_b" {
  function_name = local.lambda_functions.function_b.name
  # ... other function configurations
}

Explanation:

1. The Cycle: The commented-out aws_lambda_function resources demonstrate the cycle. Each function depends on the other's log group, creating a circular dependency.

2. The Solution: We remove the depends_on blocks from the Lambda function definitions. In this case, the dependency is unnecessary because Lambda functions automatically create their log groups if they don't exist.

3. Implicit Dependency: Even without explicit depends_on, Terraform understands the implicit dependency between a Lambda function and its log group. It will ensure the log group is created before the function.

Running the Code:

1. Save the code as main.tf.
2. Run terraform init to initialize your Terraform working directory.
3. Run terraform plan to see the execution plan. You'll notice Terraform correctly identifies the implicit dependencies.
4. Run terraform apply to apply the changes to your infrastructure.

Visualizing with terraform graph:

1. Run terraform graph to generate a visual representation of your infrastructure dependencies.
2. Open the generated .png file to see the graph. You'll notice the absence of a cycle after the fix.

This example demonstrates a simple cycle scenario and its resolution. In more complex cases, you might need to employ other techniques like restructuring your code or using temporary resources to break the cycle. Remember to analyze your dependencies carefully and use tools like terraform graph to visualize and understand your infrastructure relationships.

• Common Causes of Cycles:

  • Shared Resources: Multiple resources trying to manage the same component (e.g., two resources defining the same security group rule).
  • Overlapping Responsibilities: Modules or parts of your code attempting to manage resources that should be handled by a different part.
  • Complex Dependencies: Large projects with intricate relationships between resources can easily lead to cycles if not carefully designed.

• Debugging Strategies:

  • Isolate the Cycle: Comment out sections of your code or use terraform plan -target= to focus on specific resources involved in the cycle.
  • Examine Resource Attributes: Pay close attention to how resource attributes are referenced. A seemingly minor change in an attribute reference can introduce a cycle.
  • Leverage Terraform State: Inspect your Terraform state file (using terraform state show or terraform state pull) to understand the current relationships between resources.

• Best Practices for Cycle Prevention:

  • Clear Resource Ownership: Define clear boundaries for which parts of your code manage which resources.
  • Favor Loose Coupling: Design your infrastructure with minimal dependencies between resources whenever possible.
  • Iterative Development: Build your infrastructure incrementally, testing frequently to catch cycles early on.
  • Code Reviews: Have another team member review your code for potential cycles, especially for complex configurations.

• Advanced Techniques:

  • Terraform 0.13+ for_each: The for_each meta-argument can help restructure resources and dependencies to avoid cycles in many cases.
  • Data Sources: Use data sources to fetch information about existing resources instead of creating dependencies on their creation.

Remember, resolving Terraform cycles is often about understanding the underlying logic of your infrastructure and finding ways to break circular relationships without compromising functionality.

Terraform cycles, caused by circular dependencies between resources, can bring your infrastructure deployments to a standstill. By understanding the nature of these cycles, diligently reviewing explicit (depends_on) and implicit dependencies, and employing strategies like code restructuring or temporary resources, you can effectively break these cycles. Tools like terraform graph and best practices such as modular code design and consistent variable usage are invaluable for both identifying and preventing cycles. Remember, a well-structured and clearly defined Terraform configuration is key to avoiding these circular dependencies and ensuring smooth and successful infrastructure provisioning.

• How to Use Terraform Variables: Examples & Best Practices | Terraform variables types and how to use them. Learn how to use local, input, output, and environment variables. See how to mark Terraform variables as sensitive.
• Terraform + DynamoDB: All attributes must be indexed - Stack ... | Apr 24, 2018 ... attribute blocks inside aws_dynamodb_table resources are not defining which attributes you can use in your application. They are defining ...
• aws_api_gateway_rest_api | Resources | hashicorp/aws | Terraform ... | Manages an API Gateway REST API. The REST API can be configured via importing an OpenAPI specification in the body argument (with other arguments serving as ...
• amazon web services - Accessing Terraform variables within ... | Jun 13, 2018 ... variable2 public_alb_dns = local.private_alb_dns } )) .... } You can also access other terraform resource attribute references.
• aws_s3_bucket | Resources | hashicorp/aws | Terraform | Terraform ... | ... Terraform may view the policy as constantly changing in a terraform plan . ... This resource exports the following attributes in addition to the arguments above:.
• Import your Google Cloud resources into Terraform state | Terraform can import existing infrastructure. This allows you to take resources you've created by some other means and bring them under Terraform management.
• aws_sns_topic_subscription | Resources | hashicorp/aws | Terraform | The most likely use case for Terraform users will probably be SQS queues. NOTE: If the SNS topic and SQS queue are in different AWS regions, the ...
• Provisioner: remote-exec | Terraform | HashiCorp Developer | The remote-exec provisioner invokes a script on a remote resource after it is created. This can be used to run a configuration management tool, bootstrap into ...
• azurerm_app_service | Resources | hashicorp/azurerm | Terraform ... | ... otherwise uses Git. Attributes Reference. In addition to the Arguments listed above - the following Attributes are exported: id - The ID of the App Service ...